Is it the Lighting?
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 5:28am
Post 1 of 25
I have a green screen (More like an expensive green sheet). Well, anyway when i film in front of it, and i bring it into Vegas 5 and Chroma Key it. Parts of me are transparent. I'm new at greenscreening(?) and im wondering if its the lighting. or the distance?
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 9:33am
Post 2 of 25
We can't really tell unless you show us a picture of the greenscreen.
Different programs handle greenscreen differently, too. Some require perfect screens, while others can handle lower quality ones.
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 3:24pm
Post 3 of 25
Chromanator is the best at keying poor greenscreens. http://fxhome.com/chromanator/
Try out the demo on your clip. If you could post a test clip or picture, that would help us out a lot.
what type of camera are you using? MiniDV?
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 3:59pm
Post 4 of 25
I'll work on posting a pic. I downloaded the Chromanator Demo. But I can't find how to chroma key.
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 4:04pm
Post 5 of 25
Try following the Quickstart guide that is provided with the program. It serves as an introduction to the program's main interface. Once you've completed the Quickstart the rest of the program should prove to be fairly intuitive.
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 5:11pm
Post 6 of 25
Got the Chromanator to work. Love it compared to Vegas's keying. Think i might buy it, when i get the money.
Posted: Wed, 18th Aug 2004, 5:18pm
Post 7 of 25
Please post a pic so we can try key it aswell
(If you want to, that is)
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 2:20am
Post 8 of 25
I can't figure out how to put the pic on the internet, so that i can put it on here.
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 2:42am
Post 9 of 25
Dude, send it to me. I'll host it.
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 4:27am
Post 10 of 25
For hosting images goto www.imageshack.us
and then just copy the link they give you that says "post it in a forum."
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 4:54am
Post 11 of 25
here is the original screenshot
here is the one with the vegas 5 chroma key
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 5:02am
Post 12 of 25
definately your lighting.
Cant even get a good key in chromy...
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 5:16am
Post 13 of 25
what do you suggest?
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 5:26am
Post 14 of 25
light it better. normal household lights will do. a good way is to shine 3 lights on the subject and screen. and then two lights behind the subject to create a backlight to contrast between actor and screen.
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 5:40am
Post 15 of 25
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 12:54pm
Post 16 of 25
That's the best I could get with Chromanantor due to the low color and bad lighting.
Still, a world of a diffrence compared to Vegas, but still not to good. Further examination of your clip appears that you lighted it none, or not good at all. There is a very low saturation to a point where it's almost black and white, but it still has a hint of color.
My advice: Buy Chromanator and get you some floodlights!
Posted: Thu, 19th Aug 2004, 5:07pm
Post 17 of 25
Heres my composite using chromanator. (no garbage mats etc.)
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 3:12am
Post 18 of 25
Vegas is a great program for NLE, but it's keyer sucks!
On lighting... Light the screen with a different (or several different) light that you use to light yourself, and you'll want to try to avoid casting a shadow onto your screen too...
On the keying... garbage matte first then pick the green that's closest to your body first and work from there, sometimes it takes multiple passes too...
this advise applies to ANY program you use for keying, even Vegas (although not the best by a long shot)
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 3:55am
Post 19 of 25
The original shot looks like there was no light at all, not even a light in the room you have to have at least some kind of light so the screen looks a brighter green and the subject is more visable.
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 4:26am
Post 20 of 25
Although not good for greenscreening at all. The lighting quite nicely matched the Lord Of the Rings backround.
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 6:58am
Post 21 of 25
Cheap and effective … This is my lighting setup, halogen work lights from WalMart. The duel 500 watt lights on the stand cost about $35 and about $20 for the 1000 watt and $10 for the other 500 watt floor light. The wire safety grill casts shadows so you may want to take them off but be careful… these lights get extremely hot! (They don’t call ‘em safety grills for nothing!)
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 11:49am
Post 22 of 25
I have some of those too
and mostly I use the clip on work lights too, they're like a couple bucks and I get an assortment of different wattage bulbs...
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 12:46pm
Post 23 of 25
And if possible put more distance between the screen and your subjet. That will help
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 4:02pm
Post 24 of 25
I shine those big lights into umbrellas coated with foil to eliminate the base shadows and provide a good solid base light. I find shining those heavy duty lights makes really big shadows, and over lights it. not to mention it makes your actor squint...
Posted: Fri, 20th Aug 2004, 5:12pm
Post 25 of 25
And if you can't afford the lights, If I were you I would go out on a cloudy day with your GreenScreen and mother nature will help you to light your greescreen, as the weather don't create any shadows (as we all know) its great. then you might wanna do some lightning anyway, just to improve the shot a bit.