Uh..56+59=258. Do the math again.
Actually, the counter is messed up. It adds +1 for everytime someone clicks it. So say you click it to start downloading, but it messes up. Then you click again to start it. You finally get it done, then you decide to watch it again later. Thats 3 right there. Or if you have a download resumer, which seem to be pretty popular nowadays, it wouldn't be exagerating to say you could download the file 10+ times. If only a few people do that, you have a screwy value. Make sense?